Recipes
5 minute read

Sardine Pie: A Recipe for the Brave

Written by
Nathan Cafearo
Published on
July 1, 2025

Sorry, Did You Say Sardine Pie?

You came here for gastronomic inspiration, and instead, you’ve found the sardine pie recipe. Congratulations. Either you have an open mind, or you just typed with your elbows. If fish pie made you cringe, welcome to its bolder, saltier cousin—the dish that's unashamedly cheap, divisive, and smells like your gym socks if you wore them for a week. Strap in, food lovers. This one separates the culinary thrill-seekers from the, let’s say, people who pour milk before their cereal.

What’s Lurking in This Pie?

Let’s see what glorious ingredients will turn your kitchen into a fragrant homage to coastal living (or the inside of a fishmonger's boot):

  • Two tins of sardines in oil (if you can find them in spring water, why are you even here?)
  • One onion, chopped (go wild, cry)
  • Three cloves garlic, minced (because you have nowhere to be tonight)
  • Two medium potatoes, peeled and cubed
  • One pastry sheet (store-bought, or make your own if you hate free time)
  • One egg, beaten (for glazing, not for an existential crisis)
  • One lemon, zested and juiced (optional, but why not add some class?)
  • Parsley, chopped, to garnish (elevates the looks, not the taste)
  • Pinch of salt and black pepper (as if the sardines weren’t enough)
  • Olive oil (drizzle extravagantly, count it as self-care)

How to Build Your Masterpiece

  1. Preheat the oven to 200°C (390°F). Yes, your oven actually works for things other than frozen pizza.
  2. Boil the potatoes until tender, about 10 minutes. Less time than it takes to question this pie’s existence.
  3. Heat olive oil in a pan. Sauté onion and garlic until translucent and your neighbors start checking their deodorisers.
  4. Add sardines (with oil) to the pan. Mash lightly, resist the urge to call for backup. Add lemon zest, juice, salt, and pepper.
  5. Add boiled potatoes and stir until everything is coated in, shall we say, "umami optimism." Remove from heat.
  6. Roll out your pastry and line a pie dish. Pour the fishy mixture in like you’re sharing a secret with the universe.
  7. Cover with more pastry, pinch the edges. Stab the top with a fork—pretend it’s someone who offered you tuna instead.
  8. Brush with egg wash. Optional: carve a fishy motif if you want to scare future generations.
  9. Bake for 25-30 minutes or until golden brown and smelling like you’ve made a life choice too bold to back down from.

Tipping the Scales: Tricks and Variations

  • Not a sardine fan? Substitute mackerel. Or salmon, if you insist on being basic.
  • Add capers or olives. Because at this point, why not drive away all your friends?
  • Gluten-free? Use GF pastry—and maybe some therapy.
  • Spice it up: a dash of cayenne will mask most regrets.
  • Feeling fancy? Serve with a salad. You can pretend it’s Mediterranean and ignore the horrified looks from your dinner guests.

Sardine Pie: The (Un)Healthy Truth

Here's what you get per serving (of questionable size):

Nutrient Amount
Calories ~320 kcal
Protein ~15g
Fat ~18g
Carbs ~28g
Omega-3 Off the charts
Dignity Variable

Rich in calcium, Vitamin D, and omega-3. Not so great for first dates, unless your type is evolutionary biologist.

Do You Dare?

Sardine pie: the recipe that divides families, strengthens immune systems, and reminds us why some cans are better left unopened. If you try it, congratulations—you're the hero in your own sitcom, and probably in need of better hobbies. Share your creation on social media, if you want to weed out the weak from your follower list.

Want more dubious delights? Stick around! There’s always another unexplored tin at the back of the pantry.

Emily Clark
Home Cook

"This blog has transformed my cooking skills! I find the recipes easy to follow and incredibly delicious."

Join the Conversation Today!

Share your thoughts, connect with us, and never miss a delicious update again!